6. Frequently asked questions
What is Thermal Energy Storage (TES) in plain terms?
It is a giant thermos for heat or cold. You heat up something cheap like sand, brick, or water (or freeze ice) when electricity is cheap or the sun is shining, keep it inside thick insulation, and draw that heat or cold out hours or days later when a home, building, or factory needs it.
Is storing heat the same as storing electricity?
No. Electricity is flexible energy (kWh(e)) that can run phones, motors, lights, or heaters. Heat and cold are thermal energy (kWh(th)) tied to temperature. Turning 1 unit of electricity into heat is easy (almost 100% turns into heat), and a chiller can move 2.5 to 5 units of cold for every 1 unit of power. Turning stored heat back into electricity is much harder and loses most of the energy as waste heat.
Why is turning stored heat back into electricity so inefficient?
Physics sets a hard ceiling called the Carnot limit, which depends on how hot the store is compared to the outside air (measured in Kelvin). A 600°C sand or salt tank in 25°C weather hits a 66% theoretical cap, and real steam turbines or engines only capture about half of that, leaving roughly 25% to 35% of the electricity you started with. That is why startups trying to make electricity from heat push temperatures past 1,500°C using glowing-heat solar cells (TPV) or use heat-pump storage loops (PTES).
When does a thermal battery beat a lithium-ion battery?
Whenever you actually want heat or cold at the end. Factories drying food, making steam, heating towns, or cooling office towers do not need electricity at the final step. Storing cheap solar or night-time power straight as heat (80% to 95% efficiency) or ice (2.5 to 5 units of cooling per unit of power) usually costs far less per kWh than a lithium-ion pack, and the hardware has no cycle wear to speak of.
When does lithium-ion beat thermal storage?
When you need electricity back out for 1 to 6 hours, such as electric cars, phone/home backup, and fast grid balancing. Lithium-ion gives back 85% to 90% of the electricity you put in, which no pure heat-to-electricity engine can match today.
What are the three ways thermal batteries hold energy?
First, warming up or cooling down a material without melting it (sensible heat, like hot sand, brick, or water). Second, melting or freezing a material at a steady temperature (latent heat, like freezing water into ice or using wax/salt packs called PCMs). Third, reversible chemical reactions (thermochemical), where heat separates two ingredients that sit at room temperature without leaking heat until you mix them back together.
How long has commercial cold storage existed?
More than 35 years. Ice-ball tanks like Cryogel (launched in 1989 with dimpled plastic balls that flex as water expands 9% when freezing) and ice-coil tanks like CALMAC (now Trane IceBank, since the 1980s) have been shifting office and campus cooling loads to night-time power for decades.
Why do ice batteries use saltwater or glycol instead of plain water in the pipes?
Plain water freezes solid at 0°C, which would clog and burst the pipes before the ice tank finishes freezing. A chilled glycol mix or saltwater brine stays liquid down to -5°C to -21°C, so it can freeze the water inside the moulds or balls at night and carry cold out to the air-conditioning loop during the hot afternoon.
Why do huge sand silos hold heat for weeks while small prototypes cool down overnight?
The amount of heat you can store grows with the inside volume, while heat leaks out through the outside walls. Double every side of a box and you hold 8 times more heat with only 4 times more wall area. My own 20 kg bench test (Sand Battery V0) cools down in hours. A 100 MWh town-scale sand silo loses less than 1% of its heat per day.
What do Technology Readiness Levels (TRL 1 to 9) mean?
TRL is a simple 1-to-9 score for how proven a technology is. TRL 1 to 3 means lab science and bench tests. TRL 4 to 6 means working pilot hardware tested in real conditions. TRL 7 to 8 means first full-size commercial plants. TRL 9 means proven everyday commercial hardware running at many customer sites, like Cryogel ice balls or electric steam boilers. Read the full Technology Readiness Level (TRL) definition on Wikipedia →